Vive Le Rock #88
Moderator: StanInBlack
Re: Vive Le Rock #88
When Hugh quit he didn’t go to the others and say “I think we should disband” or similar, he said “I’m leaving the Stranglers”, so shouldn’t have been surprised when (to our good fortune) they carried on without him, instead of disbanding.
Since then we’ve had a number of good, and a poor album or two, from both Hugh and the Stranglers (plus some fucking great gigs and a few excellent albums), with most (but definitely not all) from both sides being better than the last they did together.
Hopefully we’re gonna get quite a few more excellent gigs, and maybe another quality album or three.
As such I’m looking forwards to live gigs in 2022 from both The Stranglers and from Hugh and his band, as well as new albums as and when they appear.
Since then we’ve had a number of good, and a poor album or two, from both Hugh and the Stranglers (plus some fucking great gigs and a few excellent albums), with most (but definitely not all) from both sides being better than the last they did together.
Hopefully we’re gonna get quite a few more excellent gigs, and maybe another quality album or three.
As such I’m looking forwards to live gigs in 2022 from both The Stranglers and from Hugh and his band, as well as new albums as and when they appear.
Then I got tired of counting all of these blessings, and then I just got tired.
Re: Vive Le Rock #88
I would suggest you are possibly the UKs biggest Hugh fan.StanInBlack wrote:I dunno. Ask him/her.
The only thing that I can be certain of as a mere fan of his solo work is that it's almost certain to be superior to Dark Matters, because all of his proper solo work so far has been.
I'd be hard pushed to find anyone as passionate to the point of aggression against (imagined) damage to his legacy etc etc.
I would also find it hard to find anyone so into his solo work.
Lets face it, if there was a bigger fan, they would be posting on here wouldn't he/she?
The fact that he now has a tiny fanbase would strengthen my point.
In fact I would wager you are the only forum (any forum) member in the UK with a picture of Hugh as his avatar
Always an old picture, never the older craggier current Hugh.
As for his solo albums being better?
I tried listening to Monster a few times (more than some did with DM) and it just sounds tired and leaden to me.
Being one of his biggest fans is nothing to shy away from.
Whatever floats yer boat.
Sent from my SM-A226B using Tapatalk
Re: Vive Le Rock #88
Almost spot on, although you forgot our /resident expert’s Administrator partner / alter ego’s avatarricam wrote: ↑17 Dec 2021, 00:01
I would suggest you are possibly the UKs biggest Hugh fan.
I'd be hard pushed to find anyone as passionate to the point of aggression against (imagined) damage to his legacy etc etc.
I would also find it hard to find anyone so into his solo work.
Lets face it, if there was a bigger fan, they would be posting on here wouldn't he/she?
The fact that he now has a tiny fanbase would strengthen my point.
In fact I would wager you are the only forum (any forum) member in the UK with a picture of Hugh as his avatar
Always an old picture, never the older craggier current Hugh.
As for his solo albums being better?
I tried listening to Monster a few times (more than some did with DM) and it just sounds tired and leaden to me.
Being one of his biggest fans is nothing to shy away from.
Whatever floats yer boat.
Sent from my SM-A226B using Tapatalk
Then I got tired of counting all of these blessings, and then I just got tired.
- StanInBlack
- Man Of The Earth
- Posts: 5579
- Joined: 04 Apr 2002, 10:30
- Location: Durham, England.
Re: Vive Le Rock #88
...and I'm telling you that I'm not, as much of a fan of his solo work as I am. The fact that I have a picture of Hugh as my avatar is neither here nor there. My avatar could be a picture of absolutely anything and it wouldn't change the way I post one jot.
Hey, look Jim! It's yet another one that thinks we're the same person.
- theraven1979
- Maninwhite
- Posts: 36161
- Joined: 22 Dec 2001, 11:41
- Location: Saltaire
- Contact:
Re: Vive Le Rock #88
That's hilarious! - Stan isn't Hugh's biggest fan by a long stretch. I can think of another 4 people who idolise Hugh (met one at his last gig). Not every fan posts on here. You're pretty naive if you think that.
Jim
Jim
StanInBlack wrote: ↑17 Dec 2021, 00:38...and I'm telling you that I'm not, as much of a fan of his solo work as I am. The fact that I have a picture of Hugh as my avatar is neither here nor there. My avatar could be a picture of absolutely anything and it wouldn't change the way I post one jot.
Hey, look Jim! It's yet another one that thinks we're the same person.
"I bathed in sun and walked in rain
It taught me how to laugh again"
It taught me how to laugh again"
Re: Vive Le Rock #88
I always felt the way Hugh left, quit the band was a strange one. Why didn't he say to the other free members vis à vis I don't like how we work together any more and let us discuss the whole situation. If we don't find a way how I can feel comfortably I will quit the band. Maybe we should make a break for a year or so and see how we can manage it to continue or not. Just make a Telephon call to each of the three and say I quit, bye bye... strange for me.
-
- ManinBlack
- Posts: 3429
- Joined: 27 Jan 2004, 17:28
- Location: Cheshire
Re: Vive Le Rock #88
Loads of people quit things in a dramatic fashion because it feels right at the time, when other people might think there was a way to save the situation. Maybe he felt that he'd rather go than issue what amounts to an ultimatum - work my way, or I'm off. It could have been more dramatic, he could always have quit on stage. "Bu**ger this, I'm leaving the band. Now, this is 'Punch and Judy'. 1, 2, 3, 4 ... "Lafleur wrote: ↑17 Dec 2021, 10:01 I always felt the way Hugh left, quit the band was a strange one. Why didn't he say to the other free members vis à vis I don't like how we work together any more and let us discuss the whole situation. If we don't find a way how I can feel comfortably I will quit the band. Maybe we should make a break for a year or so and see how we can manage it to continue or not. Just make a Telephon call to each of the three and say I quit, bye bye... strange for me.
http://www.firenza.net - my homage to a seventies Vauxhall
- theraven1979
- Maninwhite
- Posts: 36161
- Joined: 22 Dec 2001, 11:41
- Location: Saltaire
- Contact:
Re: Vive Le Rock #88
I think there were pressures from the record company and if he was gonna do it then the time was right. Musta been stressful! Took some balls
I agree though, most bands now would've just taken a year out (the Manics did it with good affect). Back then I guess the pressure was on to deliver albums or tour.
Jim
I agree though, most bands now would've just taken a year out (the Manics did it with good affect). Back then I guess the pressure was on to deliver albums or tour.
Jim
Lafleur wrote: ↑17 Dec 2021, 10:01 I always felt the way Hugh left, quit the band was a strange one. Why didn't he say to the other free members vis à vis I don't like how we work together any more and let us discuss the whole situation. If we don't find a way how I can feel comfortably I will quit the band. Maybe we should make a break for a year or so and see how we can manage it to continue or not. Just make a Telephon call to each of the three and say I quit, bye bye... strange for me.
"I bathed in sun and walked in rain
It taught me how to laugh again"
It taught me how to laugh again"
- sendwarrior
- Rats Rally
- Posts: 307
- Joined: 01 Jul 2020, 19:55
- Location: In The Shadows
Re: Vive Le Rock #88
Some on here are working from the mistaken beilief that Shug was entirely responsible for all the MK1 hit songs, and therefore of far greater importance than as a mere 1/4 of the band..
The fact is that Mr Greenfield was mainly responsible for their greatest hit (Golden Brown) and arguably his keyboard work made many of their songs stand out. The other indispuatable fact is that Mr Burnel was an equal force in the song writing and his contribution on bass and vocals can hardly be considered minor. And finally the band wouldn't have even got off the ground if it wasn't for Mr Black giving them a place to live, a tour (ice cream) van and the benefit of his business acumen, not to mention his unique drumming style.
But hey, some people believe Trump and Johnson, so the facts don't really matter do they?
The fact is that Mr Greenfield was mainly responsible for their greatest hit (Golden Brown) and arguably his keyboard work made many of their songs stand out. The other indispuatable fact is that Mr Burnel was an equal force in the song writing and his contribution on bass and vocals can hardly be considered minor. And finally the band wouldn't have even got off the ground if it wasn't for Mr Black giving them a place to live, a tour (ice cream) van and the benefit of his business acumen, not to mention his unique drumming style.
But hey, some people believe Trump and Johnson, so the facts don't really matter do they?
UNBROKEN
Re: Vive Le Rock #88
Spot on.sendwarrior wrote:Some on here are working from the mistaken beilief that Shug was entirely responsible for all the MK1 hit songs, and therefore of far greater importance than as a mere 1/4 of the band..
The fact is that Mr Greenfield was mainly responsible for their greatest hit (Golden Brown) and arguably his keyboard work made many of their songs stand out. The other indispuatable fact is that Mr Burnel was an equal force in the song writing and his contribution on bass and vocals can hardly be considered minor. And finally the band wouldn't have even got off the ground if it wasn't for Mr Black giving them a place to live, a tour (ice cream) van and the benefit of his business acumen, not to mention his unique drumming style.
But hey, some people believe Trump and Johnson, so the facts don't really matter do they?
Sent from my SM-A226B using Tapatalk
Re: Vive Le Rock #88
When we all know that he's only responsible when we're talking about songs and albums we don't like.Some on here are working from the mistaken beilief that Shug was entirely responsible for all the MK1 hit songs, and therefore of far greater importance than as a mere 1/4 of the band..
It's only on this forum where the lyricist and arranger of a song has virtually no input.The fact is that Mr Greenfield was mainly responsible for their greatest hit (Golden Brown)
- theraven1979
- Maninwhite
- Posts: 36161
- Joined: 22 Dec 2001, 11:41
- Location: Saltaire
- Contact:
Re: Vive Le Rock #88
The Stranglers are MKI for most people. It's not JJ, it's not Hugh, it's the 4 of them that created those songs. In the example you gave with Dave it was Hugh that sat down with Dave and encouraged him to lay Golden Brown down and Hugh then added the lyrics. If it wasn't for Hugh Dave would've just had this cool keyboard part in his head forever. Also, JJ didn't want anything to do with it.
To keep the facts flowing what you have now is 1 original member just as Hugh is 1 original member also performing with the band.
No emotion in the above from me - just the facts
Jim
To keep the facts flowing what you have now is 1 original member just as Hugh is 1 original member also performing with the band.
No emotion in the above from me - just the facts
Jim
sendwarrior wrote: ↑17 Dec 2021, 10:55 Some on here are working from the mistaken beilief that Shug was entirely responsible for all the MK1 hit songs, and therefore of far greater importance than as a mere 1/4 of the band..
The fact is that Mr Greenfield was mainly responsible for their greatest hit (Golden Brown) and arguably his keyboard work made many of their songs stand out. The other indispuatable fact is that Mr Burnel was an equal force in the song writing and his contribution on bass and vocals can hardly be considered minor. And finally the band wouldn't have even got off the ground if it wasn't for Mr Black giving them a place to live, a tour (ice cream) van and the benefit of his business acumen, not to mention his unique drumming style.
But hey, some people believe Trump and Johnson, so the facts don't really matter do they?
"I bathed in sun and walked in rain
It taught me how to laugh again"
It taught me how to laugh again"