Dark Matters v Giants

[jason]

Water beats Camden

Freedom beats This song

Giants draws with Dave

Lowlands draws with If Something

No man's land beats Boom Boom

Fickle just beats Payday

Time was just beats Down

Moon beats Mercury

Stallion beats Adios

15 Steps just beats Breathe

I've left off The Lines as it's short and possibly the weakest track imo.

I make that a 4-4 draw! So not too much between the albums really.

[Jake]

About the same for me, both a bit hit and miss, and kind of forgettable in the grand scheme of the stranglers back catalogue and good music in general.

[Cricklewood]

If I do it your way...

Water vs Camden
Water

Freedom vs This song
Freedom

Giants vs Dave
Giants

Lowlands vs If Something
If Something

No Man's land vs Boom Boom
No Man's Land

Fickle vs Payday (+ The Lines)
Fickle

Time vs Down
Time Was

Moon vs Mercury
Moon

Stallion vs Adios
Stallion

15 Steps vs Breathe
Breathe

Dark Matters wins 6-4

[StanInBlack]

This is such an awful way of comparing one album with another.

[aldinblack]

I'd rather do like this:

DM good:
Water
Dave
Something
No Mans
Payday
Moon
Stallion
Breath

Meh:
Song
Lines
Down

Giants good:
Freedom
Giants
Fickle
Time
Mercury

Meh:
Camden
Lowlands
Boom
Adios
Steps

DM wins 8-5

[8088]

I prefer a more measured, scientific and quantifiable comparison....

GvsDM.jpg (25.63 KiB) Viewed 2650 times

[jetblacksdad]

My take using the science of my mind (i.e. what I like)

Dark Matters pisses on Giants

The End

[theraven1979]

Number of Times I've Played Giants: 3.5
Number of Times I've Played DM: 5


Jim

[Greatkudu]

I still like Giants, but I think DM is better. But I having a break for a few days, currently enjoying the Dave tribute CD, makes me smile hearing Daves vocals on Peasant, all his character comes out. Lt Kudu.

[ricam]

I prefer a more measured, scientific and quantifiable comparison....

GvsDM.jpg

I hope this isn't saying Giants is a fun party and DM is a catastrophic disaster.
I'm confident that isn't what you are saying .

Sent from my Moto G (5) using Tapatalk

[8088]

I prefer a more measured, scientific and quantifiable comparison....


GvsDM.jpg

I hope this isn't saying Giants is a fun party and DM is a catastrophic disaster.
I'm confident that isn't what you are saying .

Sent from my Moto G (5) using Tapatalk

You get more megatons for your money with Dark Matters

[ricam]

I prefer a more measured, scientific and quantifiable comparison....


GvsDM.jpg

I hope this isn't saying Giants is a fun party and DM is a catastrophic disaster.
I'm confident that isn't what you are saying .

Sent from my Moto G (5) using Tapatalk

You get more megatons for your money with Dark Matters

All albums should have a sticker on saying exactly that!

Sent from my Moto G (5) using Tapatalk